go to top scroll for more

UKERC response to the Department of Energy and Climate Change consultation - Electricity Market Reform

This resource links to a document we hold in our system

Abstract:

UKERC endorses the principles underlying the proposed package of reforms and supports the broad direction and aspirations of the EMR. However we believe that the package is unnecessarily complex and that some important issues, such as governance arrangements and price transparency in wholesale markets have received insufficient attention, or are absent.

A system of feed-in tariffs differentiated by and tailored to specific technologies, coupled with a capacity mechanism, would be sufficient to deliver the twin goals of promoting investment in low carbon generation and ensuring security of supply.

The feed-in tariff (FiT) is the key element of the EMR package. However, a one size fits all approach to FiT design is not appropriate. Low carbon technologies are diverse in terms of technological maturity, cost structure and risk profiles and different technologies may merit different approaches.

We regret that fixed FiTs have been excluded as they are the lowest risk option and they have a proven track record globally in encouraging investment in renewables. Contracts for differences (CfDs) may be appropriate for nuclear, while biomass generation and CCS could be supported by premium FiTs. The Emission Performance Standard (EPS) appears to be the most dispensable part of the EMR packages since other measures, such as carbon price support, will effectively inhibit investment in new unabated coal in the UK.

A capacity mechanism will be needed to give assurance that sufficient capacity will be installed to guarantee security of supply though it may be some time before the mechanism is needed.

We would recommend approaching auctions for FiTs with caution as, for many technologies, the pre-conditions for a successfulauction are not in place. These include the need for established technologies, a vibrant, diversified and competitive market, and a well developed supply chain. Administered prices or beauty contest type tenders could be used initially with a move to auctioning at a later date.

The key risk associated with the proposed package is that its complexity and uncertainty surrounding its implementation could lead to an investment hiatus threatening the attainment of both low carbon generation and security of supply goals.

Publication Year:

2011

Publisher:

UKERC

DOI:

No DOI minted

Author(s):

Skea, J., Hardy, J., Gross, R., Mitchell, C., Baker, P. and Eyre, N.

Language:

English

File Type:

application/pdf

File Size:

555799 B

Rights:

Open Access

Rights Overview:

This data may be freely used for any purpose

Further information:

N/A

Region:

United Kingdom

Publication Type:

Consultation Response

Theme(s):

UKERC Phase 2

Related Dataset(s):

No related datasets

Related Publications(s):

A review of regional and global estimates of unconventional gas resources - A report to the Energy Security Unit of the Joint Research Centre of the European commission

Briefing Note - Transforming the UK Energy System: Public Values Attitudes and Acceptability - Interim Findings - May 2012

Building a Resilient UK Energy System - Research Report

Building a Resilient UK Energy System - Working Paper

Carbon Capture and Storage Realising the potential ? (Research Report)

Carbon Capture and Storage: Analysing uncertainty

Carbon Capture and Storage: Realising the Potential? Pathways and branching points for CCS to 2030 Work Package 3, Task 6 Working Paper

Carbon Capture and Storage: Realising the Potential? Work Package 3, Task 5 Working Paper Version 2.1

Carbon Emission Accounting Balancing the books for the UK

Climate change and energy security: Assessing the impact of information and its delivery on attitudes and behaviour

Decarbonising the UK Energy System: Accelerated Development of Low Carbon Energy Supply Technologies

Electricity Demand Reduction - UKERC Consultation Response to the Department of Energy and Climate Change

Electricity Market Design for a Low-carbon Future

Electricity Market Reform Workshop III: Institutional Arrangements

Electricity Market Reform: Independent Experts Workshop

Electricity Market Reform: Stakeholders Workshop

Energy 2050 - WG1 Energy Demand : Lifestyle and Energy Consumption - working paper

Energy Materials Availability Handbook

Energy from biomass: the size of the global resource

Environmental and Eco-innovation: Concepts, Evidence and Policies

Feed in Tariffs: the energy saving option

Future Research Requirements for Smart Metering Workshop

Global Oil Depletion: An assessment of the evidence for near-term peak in global oil production

Governance: Challenges and Solutions for a Sustainable, Secure and Affordable British Energy System - Meeting Report

Great Expectations: The cost of offshore wind in UK waters understanding the past and projecting the future

House of Lords Economic Affairs Committee: Inquiry on The Economic Impact on Energy Policy of Shale Gas and Oil - Response on behalf of the UK Energy Research Centre

Low-carbon, resilient scenarios for the UK energy system in 2050

Making the transition to a secure and low-carbon energy system: synthesis report - UKERC 2050 project

Mapping rebound effects from sustainable behaviours: key concepts and literature review

Materials Availability, Working Paper I: Thin Film Photovoltaics.

Materials Availability, Working paper II: Potential constraints to the future low-carbon economy: Batteries, Magnets and Materials.

Materials Availability, Working paper III: Comparison of material criticality studies - methodologies and results.

Memorandum From Research Councils UK for the Energy and Climate Change Committee Inquiry into UK Deepwater Drilling - Implications of the Gulf of Mexico Oil Spill

Pathways to a Low Carbon Economy: Energy Systems Modelling - UKERC Energy 2050 Research Report 1

Personal Carbon Budgeting: What People Need to Know, Learn and Have in Order to Manage and Live Within a Carbon Budget, and the Policies that Could Support Them?

Policy Briefing : An introduction to ecosystem services

Presenting the Future: An assessment of future costs estimation methodologies in the electricity generation sector

Prioritising the best use of biomass resources: conceptualising trade-offs

Public Attitudes to Nuclear Power and Climate Change in Britain Two Years after the Fukushima Accident: Summary findings of a survey conducted in March 2013 - Working Paper

Public Risk Perceptions, Understandings, and Responses to Climate Change in Australia and Great Britain: Interim Report

Public opinion Energy security

Record of the UKERC-supported Wind Energy Research Road Mapping meeting

Renewable Heat Initiative - UKERC Consultation Response on Expanding the Non Domestic Scheme

Report on the evidence for net job creation from policy support for energy efficiency and renewable energy: An appraisal of multi-sectoral modelling techniques

Response to the 2011 HM Treasury Carbon Floor Price Consultation

Response to the Ofgem consultation: Project Discovery options for secure and sustainable energy supplies

Review and Analysis of UK and International Low Carbon Energy Scenarios

The Extent to Which Economic Regulation Enables the Transition to a Sustainable Electricity System

The UK bio-energy resource base to 2050: estimates, assumptions, and uncertainties

The UK energy system in 2050: Comparing Low-Carbon, Resilient Scenarios

The experience of carbon rationing action groups: implications for a personal carbon allowances policy

Transforming the UK Energy System: Public Values, Attitudes & Acceptability.Deliberating Energy System Transitions in the UK.

Transforming the UK Energy System: Public Values, Attitudes and Acceptability

Transforming the UK Energy System: Public values, attitudes and acceptability, Summary findings of a survey conducted August 2012.

UK Energy Research Centre Response to the Energy and Climate Change Committee Consultation on Consumption-based Emission Reporting.

UK Transport Carbon Model

UKCCSC and UKERC response to the Energy and Climate Change Select Committee inquiry on emissions performance standards (EPS)

UKERC Energy Research Landscape: Bioenergy for Heat, Power and Liquid transportation fuels

UKERC Energy Research Landscape: Carbon Capture and Storage

UKERC Energy Research Landscape: Coal Combustion

UKERC Energy Research Landscape: Coal Conversion

UKERC Energy Research Landscape: Electric Power Conversion

UKERC Energy Research Landscape: Energy Efficiency - Industry

UKERC Energy Research Landscape: Energy Efficiency - Transport

UKERC Energy Research Landscape: Energy Storage (2013)

UKERC Energy Research Landscape: Energy Systems Modelling

UKERC Energy Research Landscape: Fuel Cells

UKERC Energy Research Landscape: Geothermal Energy

UKERC Energy Research Landscape: Hydrogen

UKERC Energy Research Landscape: Hydropower

UKERC Energy Research Landscape: Interdisciplinary Research Centres

UKERC Energy Research Landscape: Marine Renewable Energy

UKERC Energy Research Landscape: Nuclear Fission

UKERC Energy Research Landscape: Nuclear Fusion

UKERC Energy Research Landscape: Socio-Economic Issues (2013)

UKERC Energy Research Landscape: Solar Energy

UKERC Energy Research Landscape: Wind

UKERC Energy Research landscape: OIL AND GAS

UKERC Review of Evidence for Global Oil Depletion - Technical Report 4: Decline rates and depletion rates

UKERC Review of Evidence for Global Oil Depletion - Technical Report 5: Methods of estimating ultimately recoverable resources

UKERC Review of Evidence for Global Oil Depletion - Technical Report 6: Methods of forecasting future oil supply

UKERC Review of Evidence for Global Oil Depletion - Technical Report 7 - Annex 1: Models of Global Oil Supply for the Period 2008-2030

UKERC Review of Evidence for Global Oil Depletion - Technical Report 7: Comparison of global oil supply forecasts

UKERC Review of Evidence on Global Oil Depletion - Technical Report 1: Data Sources and Issues

UKERC Review of Evidence on Global Oil Depletion - Technical Report 2: Definition and interpretation of reserve estimates

UKERC Review of Evidence on Global Oil Depletion - Technical Report 3: The Nature and Importance of Reserve Growth

UKERC Technology and Policy Assessment Cost Methodologies Project: CCGT Case Study

UKERC Technology and Policy Assessment Cost Methodologies Project: CCS Case Study

UKERC Technology and Policy Assessment Cost Methodologies Project: Nuclear Case Study

UKERC Technology and Policy Assessment Cost Methodologies Project: Offshore Wind Case Study

UKERC Technology and Policy Assessment Cost Methodologies Project: Onshore Wind Case Study

UKERC Technology and Policy Assessment Cost Methodologies Project: PV Case Study

UKERC response to the DECC consultation on the proposed RHI financial support scheme

UKERC response to the DECC consultation: A framework for the development of clean coal

UKERC response to the DECC consultation: Heat and Energy Saving Strategy

UKERC response to the Department of Energy and Climate Change consultation - Green Deal and Energy Company Obligation

UKERC response to the Department of Energy and Climate Change consultation - Renewable Heat Incentive: Proposals for a Domestic Scheme

UKERC response to the Energy and Climate Change Committee Inquiry into The Impact of Shale Gas on Energy Markets - October 2012, Part 1

UKERC response to the Energy and Climate Change Committee Inquiry into The Impact of Shale Gas on Energy Markets - October 2012, Part 2.

UKERC response to the Energy and Climate Change Committee's Inquiry on Heat

UKERC response to the Ofgem consultation: Project Discovery: Future Energy Markets

UKERC response to the PRASEG Inquiry - Renewables and the Grid: Access and Management

Understanding Homeowners Renovation Decisions: Findings of the VERD Project

What policies are effective at reducing carbon emissions from surface passenger transport? A review of interventions to encourage behavioural and technological change